| « David Sirota is not a smart man-Idea from Huffington Post | Glenn Greenwald is a smart liberal » |
Murder as Genetic Disease or Earthquake
08/20/07
I was enjoying my Frantone's Lasagna and reading the Los Angeles Times when I came upon an article entitled Murder Stalks Minorities by Jill Leovy:
First the excerpt:
Continue below:
Follow up:
Homicide is not fair, hitting hardest among Latinos and especially among blacks. Latinos are killed at more than three times the rate of whites, while blacks succumb to homicide at three times the rate of Latinos, the Times analysis shows.
Adult males are the eye of the storm. The national homicide rate is about six deaths per 100,000 people each year. But for Latino men in their 20s in Los Angeles County, the rate is 52 deaths, and for black men, 176 deaths. In human terms, that means that losing a son to homicide, a remote possibility in some neighborhoods, looms as a daily threat in others.
In South Los Angeles and Athens this year, for example, there have been at least 20 homicides within a single ZIP Code in just seven months. A few miles away, in the Woodland Hills, Tarzana and Brentwood ZIP Codes, months go by without any....
...But no matter how they work to avoid it, the demographics of homicide ruthlessly pursues its targets. In parts of South Los Angeles, for example, there are people who have lost not one, but two or more family members. Michael Presley, 19, killed in the Los Angeles Police Department's Southwest Division, was buried in the same grave as his father, also a murder victim.
Ms. Leovy writes as if murder were a disease that attacks people of a certain genetic disposition like Sickle Cell Anemia or Tay Sachs. Murder is a behavior. The reason that some neighborhoods or races kill less than others is that they choose alternative activities like studying or working. If people in high crime areas followed the example of those in Woodland Hills and stopped killing each other, the murder rate would fall dramatically (I wish they'd try and see).
It's not like a hurricane or earthquake either. In other words, many of those victims aren't minding their own business and then, all of a sudden, they're consumed in a twister; they involve themselves in things that increase their chance of dying like gangs. God bless the innocent, though.
PermalinkCategories: Los Angeles/Orange County :: 8 comments »
8 comments
Sooo Catholic.
How kind of you.
Chris
Mr. Paine
Still, it doesnt make it right, and I hope you stop doing it, I know it can be done.
Chris
I don't know about all the people murdered in South LA lately (and maybe it's true for many), but in the case of at least three of them... Nothing could be further from the truth.
I'm on staff on my university's paper (CSUN's Daily Sundial), and I was assigned to photograph for the story about Michael Presley (mentioned in the Times quote). After I'd met his mother, grandmother and sister, it was like I knew him, and a worse tragedy couldn't have befallen a better family. Other than an extremely supportive upbringing, this kid had an excellent grade point average, scholarship offers, and -- unlike a lot of students I know -- really loved school. He was only in South LA after visiting his family for the weekend; he lived in the dorms in Northridge.
Two other CSUN students were murdered this summmer. One was an art student who on his way to meet his sister was gunned down at a bus stop because he happened to be wearing a lot of red, the colors of the "blue" gang's rivals. I know less about the third one, but he wasn't in a gang, either.
"Most of the people murdered involve themselves in criminal activity. They're gang members, etc."
I guess it just sounds like you are throwing everyone into your idea and or concept of what criminals are, then when someone calls oyu on your faulty reasining and logic, you flop. How quaint.







