| « Catholics still have great political influence in Philippines | Pope tells drug dealers to watch their back » |
Pope fighting good fight in Brazil
05/13/07
In this story the Pope assails both Capitalism and Communism. When the Popes have talked about economic matters, they've usually not distinguished themselves. What the Pope should emphasize (economic models are opinions based on what one thinks would be the most expedient for the Church and the most likely to produce a good society- the Pope's isn't necessarily more valuable than mine; it's not dogma) is charity, which is a Church requirement. The method people deliver charity-whether by the government or, as I prefer, by private individuals and the marketplace, should be outside the Church's purview unless you think the Church should dictate tax rates or institute rent control.
It's kind of like blaming freedom for adultery or premarital sex. The problem isn't that we don't stone adulteresses; it's that people aren't committed to marriage. The problem isn't that capitalism breeds selfishness; it's that people are selfish. And they'd be selfish no matter what system existed.
maybe he wanted to attack Communism but didn't want to come off sounding biased, "Hey, it's not just you. These guys have their problems too"
The Pope is correct, however, when he talks about abortion or premarital sex as those are, in and of themselves, bad, according to Church dogma. And it's a tough sell. But, what can he do? He has to say it.








